thehomeland.org - main menu

Collected Short Story Summaries

I own several printed short story collections as part of the broader Miccmo Collection, mostly of the oldschool mass-media paperback variety. Below is a list of those publications, the contents therein, and my summaries of those stories.

text spacing

text spacing

text spacing

text spacing

text spacing

text spacing

text spacing

1968, Asimov's Mysteries, Fawcett Crest Books


Page Title Author
15 The Singing Bell Isaac Asimov
33 The Talking Stone Isaac Asimov
54 What's In A Name? Isaac Asimov
71 The Dying Night Isaac Asimov
99 Pate de Foie Gras Isaac Asimov
116 The Dust of Death Isaac Asimov
129 A Loint of Paw Isaac Asimov
131 I'm in Marsport Without Hilda Isaac Asimov
146 Marooned Off Vesta Isaac Asimov
163 Anniversary Isaac Asimov
180 Obituary Isaac Asimov
198 Star Light Isaac Asimov
203 The Key Isaac Asimov
236 The Billiard Ball Isaac Asimov
Title: “The Singing Bell” Author: Isaac Asimov

Basics: A criminal mastermind devises a plan to murder his own accomplice in a big heist of moon-based mining valuables.

In depth: Louis Peyton is a criminal who has, throughout his career, foiled the authorities countless times, with two driving principles: (a) that one must not create a pattern which leads to the crime since said pattern will identify the criminal; one must find an existing pattern and adjust to it, in order to perpetrate the crime, and (b) that is far better to have no alibi than to have an alibi which could be disproven.

Albert Cornwell, a “small-time retailer of stolen things,” approaches Peyton with a proposal to collect a cache of “singing bells” from the moon, after a researcher of said bells discovered a large cache of them and met an untimely demise. Albert obtained the researcher's map, therefore gaining insight to the locate of the cache. Retrieval of said cache and thenceforth sale of said would lead to a mutual retirement of vast affluence, each. Cornwell has the location of the cache, and Peyton has the ship and contacts for their dispersal. Cornwell makes the proposal to Peyton, to be perpetrated in several months' time from now, August. 50-50.

August was a sacred time for Peyton, however. For one month out of the year Peyton would retreat to a secluded prepper-bunker, and it was always in August. He even broke out of jail once to ensure his August retreat pattern could resume.

Come August, Peyton played out the role of preparing the compound for his stay, placing the same orders he always did for supplies, ordering the same transport of himself and of goods, to make it appear as if he would do the same as had prior years. This year, however, he destroyed the goods with very little evidence, so that if the compound were raided to find he had been gone and not consumed the normal goods as evidence he had not been there, it would appear as if he had consumed them over the course of that month.

The ship arrived and took them both up to the moon. The map was unclear to some degree, in that the cache could be in one of 3 spots. They landed in a place, waited for the sun to set as they acclimated to the low-grav environment, and set out for each of the 3 spots, beginning with the closest. They spent much of the time traveling to and from the craft, as the cold took a toll on their bodies. Travel to the first spot revealed nothing. They realized that traveling to the third spot would take too long with their current method, so hoped it was at the 2nd spot, and it was.

The Singing Bells were irregular masses of gray rock, as large as a double fist, feather light in the moon's gravity, and could be sold for $100k each of the 2 dozen found, once polished. The story was published in 1955, so $100k adjusted for 2026 inflation is $1.218mil, each. Earlier Peyton had tipped two others a “generous” $10, or $120. As they finished loading the bells to the craft, Peyton weapon-blasted Cornwell who was the last to board, dead.

Peyton takes off in the ship, lands back in the launch site (using anti-grav tech, so no rockets needed), hides the bells, and sets the ship to an unsafe and bent-controls direction, it takes off and explodes into disintegration. Peyton travels back to his compound and rests. Not a day later, the police arrive.

Elsewhere, Terrestrial Bureau of Investigations inspector H. Seton Davenport makes contact with Dr Wendell Urth (a recurring character in Asimov's mysteries), who is an “extraterrologist” but who prefers to remain on earth, much like, Urth reasons, how a historian does not require time travel to study history. Urth's expertise is desired, to assist with the solving of the first-ever moon murder. Details of the case are described to Urth, and Urth recognizes the locations of the places footprints were found traveling to, the places Singing Bells would be found, and reports of a bright flash of light seen from a vast distance on the dark side of the moon, presumably the weapon's energy blast which killed Cornwell.

Urth perks up at the mention of Singing Bells being involved. He takes the inspector to a museum room, and shows him a very flawed such Singing Bell, which was given to him from findings of an expedition. Urth stroked the bell with a special carved-bone instrument, and it created a surreal sound. This being a flawed one, surely the perfect kind would make “this one sound like a child's harmonica,” and be worth a fortune, but they are dreadfully hard to find, and the theory of their composition belies any attempts at artificial craft of it, so it is surrounded in mystery.

Peyton's distinct lack of alibi, in that he was observed by no one and has an established pattern of seclusion to the point of obsession of this seclusion, is the non-alibi Peyton possesses. The pattern of having never been observed by anyone, anywhere, during August, rules out Peyton as the perpetrator, yet Davenport is resolute that Peyton is the murderer.

A psychoprobe is a kind of technology which exists in their world, which probes the psyche of an individual for facts which can be used in court. However, a law, the Konski-Hiakawa law, states that no person can be psychoprobed twice in their lifetime. The use of the probe is a method of pre-trial confidence in the accused, to the point where a case as severe as murder, but without using the psychoprobe, is laughed out of court because the prosecution is not confident enough in their case to have not used the probe. Misuse of the probe, however, can lead to both massive suits against false use of it, as well as near-complete legal immunity due to the never-twice rule so that criminals can enjoy virtual freedom to commit since the probe can never be used on them again to prove other crimes.

Urth decides he needs to interview Peyton, in order to prove Peyton was the murderer. Urth despises all non-foot travel, so proposes Davenport bring Peyton to City Hall, within walking distance. Davenport instead offers to bring Peyton to Urth's residence, and it is agreed.

Urth interviews Peyton, and during the interview tosses Peyton his flawed Singing Bell. Davenport and Peyton both are shocked that Urth would do such a thing to something so valuable. Urth then asks Peyton to toss it back, but the bell only travels a third of the way to Urth, and then shatters onto the floor. Urth reasons that, although in environment suits, one has exposure to earth air the entire trip there, one does not experience Earth gravity while on the moon. The adaptation to the moon's gravity caused Peyton's reaction level of the fully acknowledged highly valuable bell to not make it to its intended destination fully, as evidence Peyton must have been to the moon, as Peyton would not have willingly destroyed the bell. Urth's conclusion would be enough to warrant use of the psychoprobe, and seal the conviction.

Title: “The Talking Stone” Author: Isaac Asimov

Basics: A chipper asteroid belt station engineer encounters a grouchy delivery ship captain with a stuttering hyperatomic engine.

In depth: Larry Vernadsky is a happy-skippy cheerful person, who craves interactions with people, but is stationed on a solitary (and to him, prison-like) station on a hollowed-out asteroid in the asteroid belt. Larry's station gets docked by the Robert Q, a transport ship helmed by a captain who craves little else than resuming his journey. The captain's name is not revealed during their interactions.

Larry jots down the verbally-answered check-in details (2 crew, not including the captain apparently), then isolates the problem with the engine, but it will take upwards of 12 hours plus, particularly due to a lengthy system flush in order to gain access to vital bits. During the flush, Larry spots a creature called a “silicony” which the captain reveals as a pet, kept similarly as others keep dogs.

Larry has been reading a lot about them, but has never actually seen one, and prods the captain to let him see it (noting that some have documented their ability to speak, and to read minds) and the captain relents. They go look at it, and a description of as gray, ugly, and unfamiliar, with numerous appendages. Larry is further interested in that it's about a foot long, whereas the largest anyone has found today to his knowledge, is around 2 inches, and could easily be sold for “a couple thousand” dollars (in Oct 1955 when this was published, $1k would be adj-inf to 2026 as $12k) on earth, but the captain seems uninterested.

As the captain is of the attitude, “well you saw it, let's go” level of disinterest in the encounter, the silicony speaks, and recites some solar system facts. Larry wants to know how it knew that, and the captain mentions having read to it some old pre-space-travel books about the system. The captain insists on returning to the task so he can be off.

Larry checks the flush, and finds it suitable so the repair can begin, and does so. Emerging from the finished repair, Larry marvels that this creature has only known asteroids its whole life, potentially hundreds of years. The captain wants to go, and that's the last thing Larry hears from him. The captain boards his ship and blasts away.

Turns out Larry has an asteroid belt police buddy named Milt Hawkins, and uses their equivalent of a telephone to chat. Larry cites the work of Dr Wendell Urth, acclaimed extraterrologist, who describes ear-like appendages of siliconies as gamma-ray detectors. Since most siliconies are only an inch or so large, and they flourish the most on gamma rays, AND since uranium mining is strictly state-run-monopoly operations, this captain could be a uranium smuggler, since the uranium detection sensors are very difficult to acquire, and these creatures can detect the gamma radiation. The fact that the silicony is so large indicates that it came from a gamma-emitting asteroid which the captain must surely know about, and likely may be illegally mining. Larry convinces the officer to tail the captain, under suspicion of uranium smuggling, for a potential promotion and so Larry can be assigned elsewhere, perhaps earthside. Larry rigged the captain's ship to only make it so far, so the cruiser should be able to intercept.

Larry and Milt zip over in the cruiser, to find the captain's ship adrift due to a meteor collision, and upon boarding realize all 3 in the compartment have died, one by blunt impact to the interior by the force of the collision, and the others by exposure (or lack thereof) to direct space. Larry and Milt fret that Larry's deliberate misrepair (if the crew are innocent) could amount to murder, but soon discover that the storage does contain the uranium contraband, so their deaths are not to Larry's credit, as it was intended to thwart crime, not cause it.

Soon, they realize they'll never be able to find the uranium asteroid now, but realize the silicony may still be alive, find it, and store it in the cruiser. Since there is no air, and the two are using radio between suits to communicate, they can't hear the silicony speak, if it even is.

They bring it aboard the cruiser, which is apparently large enough to stand in and move around. The silicony is discovered to be damaged from the impact also, and can answer and read minds, but doesn't give many useful answers to location of the asteroid, but is dying. The silicony wonders aloud what comes after death repeatedly, revealing that the captain did write down the coordinates to the asteroid, but they were written down on the asteroid, not here.

The silicony dies, and the two wonder why the captain would enscribe the asteroid coordinates on the asteroid itself, akin to locking a key to a cabinet inside the cabinet itself.

In the final scene on Earth, the inspector for the Terrestrial Bureau of Investigation, H Seton Davenport, pays Dr Wendell Urth a visit. Urth is a renowned extraterrologist, knowledgeable on everything but earth, but has not set foot more than an hour's walk outside his own house. Urth is impressed that Larry has read Urth's papers on the Siliconies, or Siliconeus asteroidea, and speaks largely incredulously with Davenport about all the clues of the case.

In exchange for revealing the location of the asteroid in question, Urth desires one large silicony of his own, alive and well, free of charge. Davenport agrees, and Urth reveals that “the asteroid” which the silicony speaks is the ship itself, not knowing the difference between a ship and an asteroid, as it was read to out of a book made before space travel, where there were no ships. The silicony therefore interprets the ship itself to also be an asteroid, and suggests the coordinates were written on the ship somewhere. Upon mulling each of the serial numbers found here and there, discrepancies of such numbers were discovered, being out of range for a normal serial number of this-or-that part, revealing 2 of the coordinates. The third and missing coordinate was etched onto the outside hull, where the asteroid hit, but was recorded on Larry's docking check-in details. Davenport assures Urth the terms of the conditional bargain will be held.

Title: “What's In A Name?” Author: Isaac Asimov

Basics: An murder investigation involving possible ingestion of Potassium Cyanide.

In depth: Narrator investigates a possible murder involving two lookalike-but-unrelated science librarian junior staff. Professor Helmuth Rodney is in charge of chemical storage and is pretty lax on security of them. Louella-Marie Busch is the deceased, and her lookalike is Susan Morey. Narrator's partner is Ed Hathaway. Senior librarian is Mrs Nettler. Pete is Susan's boyfriend, who was “built like a football player, except that his profile looked as though he had never been within half a mile of the playing field.” Possible jealousy motive between Susan, “Lolly” and Pete.

The girls often drink tea together, and signs suggest one of the sugar cubes used was laced with cyanide. Other people were in the building, including a sketchy German-speaking gent, referred to as the “little German furrier” (a fur garment tailor). Mrs Nettler had refilled the sugar cubes earlier.

Susan is about to put a book away, when someone stops her and they look into it. Prof Rodney describes it as super valuable; it is one from the highly useful and highly treasured Beilstein collection: super out of date, but nothing comparable exists in English yet and this series in all German. In the next room, the professor and narrator bandy about possibilities and motives, and use the word “hocused” twice (to deceive) and Rodney suspects Susan. Back in the library, Ed has a different bad theory and reveals he's torn a page from the beloved volume and the professor shrieks and takes it back and examines it delicately.

Later the furrier (among others) is brought before Susan and narrator to explain his actions with the two girls so that the narrator can infer which of the two was preparing tea in the back room while the other was at the desk. He initially believes it was Susan he spoke with (thus making Louella the tea-maker), but after a picture of Louella is produced he is unsure because they look too similar. Susan states she was at the counter to greet the furrier (thus she would not be the one to be making the tea). Furrier claims to have stated his name, requested a book, and gone to research moth repellents.

Others are interviewed with Susan present, and later the narrator presses upon Susan to recall the name of the German guy. She claims he mentioned his name to her when approaching the counter, but she couldn't remember it. That detail reveals she is lying, because his last name is Beilstein, and there's no way anyone working in this science library would forget that name, thus meaning it would have been Susan preparing the tea and Lou at the desk to greet the furrier.

Title: “The Dying Night” Author: Isaac Asimov

Basics: A murder investigation involving four classmates, one of whom discovered scientific teleportation, but died.

In depth: Edward Talliaferro, Stanley Kaunas, and Battersly Ryger, all meet up in Stanley's room. The trio are ill-at-ease due to the differences in gravity or environment, having returned to Earth from their solar system outposts: Edward from the moon, Stanley from Mercury, and Battersly from Ceres.

Ryger brings up the subject of a fourth colleague, Romano Villiers, who claims to have discovered a “mass transference through space” concept. Villiers had grown so ill during their mutual study which academically propelled the other 3 to observatories in the system, but Villiers' condition meant that such travel would be deadly to him.

The matter of his illness was a concern to them, but they feared he'd gone mental about or because of it. They'd tried to express grief to him, but he turned to them in anger, and that was the last they'd known of his attitude toward him. Villiers had even broken Ryger's nose over it, those 10 years ago.

Stanley mentions that, not only is Villiers attending the convention, but he's on his way to that very room. Ryger wishes to leave, but agreement is made to meet him.

Villiers enters, a shamble of a man they once new, but appears still the braggart. He seems to greet the trio kindly, but then launches into his own greatness. He developed a method of mass transference, and describes basically a teleporter device, which can send a mouse from one side of the room to the next. He proved it to someone named Mandel, and believes Mandel will give him space to show it off. He will present his findings at the convention, but without billing or announcement. He intends to demonstrate it, explain the principles behind it, and anticipates the audience to scatter to build their own devices and find it out to be true. He claims he'll be able to go to any of their observatories easily. He refuses to let any of the trio go over his findings, and has only one copy so no one will get it until the reveal.

It's worth noting that in Asimov's time, the concept of handheld devices are purely fictional. There aren't even handheld music players. Digital storage is unfamiliar to him, and magnetic storage on a hard drive is also unfamiliar to him yet. He mentions that Edward has a handheld scanner, which will convert scanned physical documents to microfilm for later development, like how photographs used to be.

The trio murmur among themselves about his madness, but realize individually that none of the trio have amounted to much, and Villiers stands to become a science superstar if this discovery is real, unhinged as he may be. They have been good science laborers, but have not transformed the science community as they had dreamed, and Villiers has a real chance to, and the best they can contribute is just cheering from the sidelines. They decide to pay him a visit before the big reveal.

In a new scene, Edward is awakened by the doorbell at 4am, rung by someone introducing himself as Hubert Mandel. Edward recognizes him as a big name in science, as Villiers had mentioned him only by surname and the trio had understood without need for elaboration before. Hubert invites Edward to go somewhere, and when the two arrive, Ryger and Battersly are already waiting. “Another reunion.”

Mandel interviews the trio, to reveal that Villiers died, and the paper he'd secreted had been vaporized. The trio describe their initial visit of his visit to them, but then a second visit of them to him, which lasted all of 2 minutes as Villiers ordered them out nearly upon arrival. Mandel described Villiers' death as failure of his weak heart.

Ryger seemed doubtful so Mandel questioned it. Ryger believed the paper was a hoax, as a fantasy for Villiers to hold onto despite his practical imprisonment on earth, and proposed he'd staged the demonstration for Mandel, but Mandel said the demonstration appeared truthful to him, being one of requiring high standards.

Mandel also revealed that he believes there was a third visit by one of the trio, intending to provoke Villiers into heart failure. Whether it was murder is uncertain, but destruction of the work seems to be a motive. Villiers had not died so simply, but had collapsed when the visitor left. Villiers had phoned Mandel and choked out broken sentences, one of which was clearly “classmate.” Each of the trio hand over their handheld scanners to be searched for scans of the paper.

Mandel takes a momentary leave to do view the scanners' contents, but advises the guilty person to confess, as any future revelation of mass transference will immediately land them in hot water, so keeping it is of no use to any of them. The trio passed the time wondering which one did it, while talking about problems involved in their fields of study at their outposts.

Mandel returns with the processed films, to no avail. Mandel then proposes they all visit Villiers' room at once to look for it, and then if finding nothing there, visit each of the trio's rooms, and if finding nothing there, involving the police. The convention doesn't begin for hours, so they have some hours to accomplish this.

Upon entering the room, Mandel opens a window to let more light in. Stanley cries out at the sudden brightness, “The sun!” and the others are ill at ease with the revealed environment outside, so accustomed to their research outposts (Stanley's was on Mercury with incessant sun). Stanley indicates there is something on the windowsill, and Mandel leaps for it, to find a strip of film hanging by a shred on a construction imperfection, now surely bathed in morning sunlight (which is how photographic film is erased). Mandel scampers away to develop it, to find that actually was the missing paper scan, but only an unusable corner of it was left intact, shaded by the snag on the imperfection.

What now? Mandel is exhausted, and concludes mass transference is now lost to genius and time until another such person can re-discover it. Seeing as there is no evidence of the paper anymore, Mandel is ready to give up, but Edward is insistent on solving the matter of who did it, rather than be shadowed over his whole career with the doubt. Mandel agrees after some discussion, and advises consult with his pal, Dr Wendell Urth, mentioned in stories prior.

The trio visit him, some 30 miles away. The trio is incredulous of the man they observe, being so fat and disorganized for someone so lauded. Mandel explains, and Urth proclaims a great interest in the subject as he is so vehemently opposed to locomotion other than the pedestrian sort.

With Urth present, Edward speaks up with a theory of who the culprit may be: Mandel. Urth calms Mandel's recoil to allow Edward to present the theory. The evidence was found on the outside window sill of Villier's room, in a hastily-stashed location that could be retrieved easily by someone who knew where it was, and would doubtful to be searched by police or otherwise. Each of the trio would not have dared opened the window, as they all agreed in previous discussion that all three of them had become so used to their own work environment outside of Earth, in that “outside” would mean instant death without a suit to protect them.

Urth shoots holes in the theory, by proposing that Mandel has done far too much to have been the criminal, most significantly by bringing up an investigation. Had he made off with the paper, it would be overwhelmingly foolish for him to accuse anyone of taking it, leading to an investigation whereby he might be discovered. Urth states that in Mandel's recounting of the thus-transpired events, he knew immediately who the guilty was.

The fact that the outside was dangerous is worth noting, but also that the outside is a safe place to store things. On the moon, the sun is visible for 2 weeks. On Ceres, 2 hours. On mercury, the sun is visible interminably, in just one direction whereas the shade is also interminable. The confidence of the shade always being a safe side, coupled with the cry of “the sun” upon realizing the sun would come up on that side thus that shade was not a safe place, revealed the culprit.

The Mercurian-Sun researcher, Stanley, confesses it wasn't planned and was all an accident, and instinctively placed the film there with the confidence Urth predicted. In the resolution, Urth mentions his non-monetary fee to Mandel: a mass-transference trip arranged for him, not to a planet, but to New Hampshire, on memory of a lovely girl he wonders whether might still be there.

Title: “Pate de Foie Gras” Author: Isaac Asimov

Basics:

In depth:

Title: “The Dust of Death” Author: Isaac Asimov

Basics:

In depth:

1967, World's Best Science Fiction, Ace Books Inc.


Page Title Author
09 We Can Remember It For You Wholesale Philip K Dick
31 Light of Other Days Bob Shaw
40 The Keys To December Roger Zelazny
65 Nine Hundred Grandmothers R A Lafferty
76 Bircher A A Walde
112 Behold The Man Michael Moorcock
163 Bumberboom Avram Davidson
198 Day Million Frederik Pohl
204 The Wings of a Bat Paul Ash
229 The Man From When Dannie Plachta
232 Amen and Out Brian W Aldiss
250 For A Breath I Tarry Roger Zelazny

1981, Chrysalis 9, Zebra Books


Page Title Author
1 A Child of Earth and Starry Heaven Somtow Sucharitkul
23 Tomorrow Mourning Nicholas V Yermakov
37 The Hashed Brown Buggy Margaret St Clair
46 Dancing in the Dark Glenn Chang
87 Orange Blossom Time Pat Murphy
101 Again, the Hit-and-Run Steve Rasnic Tem
104 A Good Place To Be Cynthia Felice
121 The Ballad of Lady Blue Karl Hansen
187 That They Be Save Al Sarrantonio
199 Hunting the Dragonblood Patrick H Adkins
215 The Sound of Hawkings Dissolving Steve Rasnic Tem
228 Gemini Tanith Lee

1960, 13 Great Stories of Science Fiction, GOLD MEDAL BOOKS


Page Title Author
11 The War is Over Algis Budrys
22 The Light Poul Anderson
34 Compassion Circuit John Wyndham
45 Volpla Wyman Guin
68 Silence, Please! Arthur C Clarke
81Allegory William T Powers
93 Soap Opera Alan Nelson
105 Shipping Clerk William Morrison
121 Technological Retreat G C Edmondson
132 The Analogues Damon Knight
144 The Available Data on the Worp Reaction Lion Miller
148 The Skills of Xanadu Theodore Sturgeon
175 The Machine Richard Gehman

1963, 17 X Infinity, Dell Publishing Co., Inc.


Page Title Author
10 The Simian Problem Hollis Alpert
20 Strikebreaker Isaac Asimov
35 Come Into My Cellar Ray Bradbury
52 Ms Find in a Lbry Hal Draper
59 Cato The Martian Howard Fast
72 The Spaceman Cometh Henry Gregor Felsen
84 The Machine Stops E M Forster
118 Frances Harkins Richard Goggin
129 The Day They Got Boston Herbert Gold
139 A-W-F, Unlimited Frank Herbert
172 As Easy As A. B. C. Rudyard Kipling
201 MacDonough's Song Rudyard Kipling
202 Silenzia Alan Nelson
216 What To Do Until The Analyst Comes Frederik Pohl
229 Short In the Chest Idris Seabright
239 The Last of the Spode Eevelyn Smith
244 Never Underestimate Theodore Spurgeon
263 Brooklyn Project William Tenn

1965, Now & Beyond, Belmont Books


Page Title Author
7 The Turning Wheel Philip K Dick
33 Unreasonable Facsimile Lester Del Rey
57 Heav'n Heav'n Eric Frank Russell
69 Venus Trap Robert Silverberg
87 Telestassis M C Pease
107 Wapshot's Demon Frederik Pohl
121 The Case For Earth Eric Frank Russell
139 The Outcasts George H Smith

1972, Where Do We Go From Here?, Fawcett Press


Page Title Author
13 A Martian Oddyssey Stanley G Weinbaum
41 Night Don A Stuart
65 The Day Is Done Lester del Rey
83 Heavy Planet Milton A Rothman
95 “–And He Built A Crooked House–” Robert A Heinlein
119 Proof Hal Celement
139 A Subway Named Mobius A J Deutsch
157 Surface Tension James Blish
195 Country Doctor William Morrison
219 The Holes Around Mars Jermone Bixby
237 The Deep Range Arthur C Clarke
249 The Cave of Night James E Gunn
267 Dust Rag Hal Clement
289 Pate de Foi Gras Isaac Asimov
307 Omnilingual H Beam Piper
351 The Big Bounce Walter S Tevis
363 Neutron Star Larry Niven

2001, Year's Best SF 6, EOS/Harper Collins


Page Title Author
1 Reef Paul J McAuley
35Reality Check David Brin
39The Millenium Express Robert Silverberg
61Patient Zero Tananarive Due
81 The Oort Crowd Kevin Macleod
85 The Thing About Benny M Shayne Bell
95 The Last Supper Brian Stableford
113Tuberculosis Bacteria Join UN Joan Slonczewski
117 Our Mortal Span Howard Waldrop
130Different Kinds of Darkness David Langford
143 New Ice Age, or Just Cold Feet? Norman Spinrad
147 The Devotee Stephen Dedman
189The Marriage of Sky and Sea Chris Beckett
210 In the Days of the Comet John M Ford
214 The Birthday of the World Ursula K Le Guin
248 Oracle Greg Egan
303 To Cuddle Amy Nancy Kress
308 Steppenpferd Brian W Aldiss
322 Sheena 5 Stephen Baxter
343 The Fire Eggs Darrell Schweitzer
358 The New Horla Robert Sheckley
372 Madame Bovary, C'est Moi Dan Simmons
377 Grandma's Jumpman Robert Reed
398 Bordeaux Mixture Charles Dexter Ward
402 The Dryad's Wedding Robert Charles Wilson
427 Built Upon the Sands of Time Michael F Flynn
445 Seventy-Two Letters Ted Chiang

1985, L Ron Hubbard Presents: Writers of the Future, Bridge Publications


Page Title Author
1 Tyson's Turn Michael D Miller
25 A Step Into Darkness Nina Hoffman
49 Tiger Hunt Jor Jennings
83 A Writer's Beginnings Robert Silverberg
89 In the Garden A J Mayhew
105 Arcadus Arcane Dennis J Pimple
125 Recalling Cinderella Karen Joy Fowler
147 The Ebbing Leonard Carpenter
185 What Are You Doing Here? Theodore Sturgeon
189The Land of the Leaves Norma Hutman
203Anthony's Wives Randell Crump
219 The Thing From the Old Seaman's Mouth Victor L Rosemund
229 Without Wings L E Carroll
245 On Science Fiction Jack Williamson
251Shanidar David Zindell
283One Last Dance Dean Wesley Smith
299Measuring The Light Michael Green
333A Way Out Mary Frances Zambreno
349 The Writer's Life and Uniqueness Roger Zelazny

1966, Selections from Adventures in Space and Time, Bantam Books


Page Title Author
1 Requiem Robert A Heinlein
19 Black Destroyer A E Van Vogt
51 Time Locker Lewis Padgett
74 Mechanical Mice Maurice A Hugi
99 As Never Was P Schuyler Miller
116 Quietus Ross Rocklynne
130 Robot's Return Robert Moore Williams
142 Farewell to the Master Harry Bates
Title: “As Never Was” Author: P Schuyler Miller

Basics: Narrator's grandfather uses a time machine to travel to the future and back with a weird knife.

In depth: A very “uses lots of words to say very little” story, musing first about what it would be like to cut another's throat, and then about the perils of time travel to the past only to return to a future that was never yours because of your impact on all of the variables not originally present in your time.

Narrator references a now in-story-famous knife that all the in-story museums speak about. Had the narrator only, he muses, used said knife on the person who tossed the knife to the table before him, before the consequences of the backward-traveling grandfather could take hold in his own timeline. The grandfather, in-story renowned archeologist Walter Toynbee, had used a time shuttle to travel into the future, retrieved the knife, and then traveled backward with it, interrupting the grandfather's timeline with a new variable.

Narrator muses that all his grandfather Walter had worked for, to bring thankless tedious archeology into modernity, only to have it wrecked by Walter's own actions, could have been preserved had he cut the throat of said traveler upon his return, but there is no way Narrator could have known to do so, being only ten at the time.

The time machine itself is a dull gray lead cube, with a big steel door which housed the weird innards, big enough to take up a quarter of the modern laboratory. Theirs was the first shuttle large enough to send a person and some belongings forward or backward. “Malecewicz” is described as its inventor, and “Balmer” as the artful designer, and it costed more than an archeology project of theirs, ever. Toynbee knew Malecewicz and where he had gone, and convinced a university to turn over his notes and worked with Balmer to devise the device.

Narrator had been waiting six hours, and the device which had been shimmering was now no longer. He looked up to see Walter had returned, very crusty from digging, who tossed a knife with a clang onto Narrator's table. Three days later, Walter died of unknown causes. He'd had supper with him, who reported being tired, but never woke the next morning.

Narrator's dad took a different path than Walter, but entertained Walter's path and supported it. Walter's death set in motion a chain of events: after the normal mourning, the press took interest in the knife. Its unknown metal, it's unfamiliar carvings, its handles mysterious composition, which no expert could suitably declare certainty. Giving up on explaining its alien craftsmanship, it was reasoned that sometime in the future we would be able to make such a thing, so time experiments became rife with many people going forward but returning empty-handed for answers.

The world was fixated on the knife now and its true development perhaps was stunted so that the timeline would never actually reach such an advancement to make it. Walter and son enjoyed archeology without such fixations, and would shudder to find what archeology now had become, a prison of the fixation of the nature of this knife. Into university, Narrator labored beneath a statistics pro who would gather absurd data sets and then make predictions of when the knife must occur, travel to that time, and each time come back empty handed – once even returning to report that the people there had not even heard of metal at all.

By age 23, Narrator was licensed to explore past and future indiscriminately. He returned with additional outlandish gadgets developed thousands of years ahead, and histories of what would occur then, which were both used and misused. Narrator realized an angle Walter used but no one else had tried: extreme travel, to the furthest possible goals. Balmer still lived, and Narrator had notes resurfaced of the original shuttle and had Balmer rebuild it to be large enough to include necessary instruments modern to Narrator's time. If you read your history, you would know not when to go because of a future war that destroyed the planet. That's where his grandfather would have gone, though, to extremes.

Narrator just so happens to end up precisely where Walter had been, as if Walter had only just left, leaving behind his equipment still in place at an ideal dig site. The shifting sands covered a lot up, but he found a shovel stuck into a crack into which sand was filling, and shoveled some to find an entrance to a tunnel. He went back to the shuttle to retrieve instruments and then went spelunking. He came upon a table, inside a room which still had Walter's boot footprints and the hand markings where he'd brushed away detritus to find the knife. He looked up from the table to a nearby wall and saw glyphs upon it.

The glyphs indicated it was a museum for the knife of Walter Toynbee. 300 years in the future, Walter would come retrieve the knife in the museum dedicated to his discovery of the knife, he would bring it back, and for 300 years the world would fixate upon it and set it into a museum as a total mystery, for a future Walter Toynbee to recover it again and bring it back again, and its origin would never, and could never, be discovered. The knife in Narrator's world had a notch in it, which was made when samples of the metals were analyzed to no avail, whereas the version Walter brought back had no notch. How could Walter have gotten it? It was too late now to know.

Navigation

most updated/flux:

—-

—-

—-

If you're a mobile browser, (a) get thee to a desktop, or (b) click Printable Version below for a less-cramped version.

Print/export
QR Code
QR Code shortstoryreview (generated for current page)